Skip to content
Call or Text Now (618) 641-9189


99% Success Rate Millions Recovered Contact Us

Can DNA Evidence Be Used Against Me in Court?

Over the last decade several TV shows like CSI, NCIS, and Law and Order have “educated” us on the use of DNA evidence in criminal cases, and, primarily, in sex crime cases.  DNA evidence is, in fact, being used throughout the country both to prosecute and defend countless individuals charged with various crimes, but that does not mean it is infallible.

In 2013, the United States Supreme Court ruled for the first time that criminal suspects can be subjected to a police DNA test after their arrest and before either a trial or conviction.  In their decision, the Supreme Court held that “when officers make an arrest supported by probable cause to hold for a serious offense and bring the suspect to the station to be detained in custody, taking and analyzing a cheek swab of the arrestee’s DNA is, like fingerprinting and photographing, a legitimate police booking procedure that is reasonable under the Fourth Amendment,” of the United States Constitution.

If the State has the right to analyze your DNA, the question becomes, is that DNA evidence admissible against you, or for your defense, in Court?  The answer is generally, but not always, yes.  If the investigators properly collected and handled the DNA evidence and the forensics scientists employed the proper and acceptable analytical methods, the evidence is, again generally, accurate and, thus, admissible in a trial.

However, DNA evidence is not above challenge.  While often accurate, errors by the individuals handling, maintaining, or collecting the DNA can contaminate the DNA sample and making it inaccurate and inadmissible at trial.  Further, there are countless examples of labs contaminating samples, failing to follow chain of custody procedures, and using unreliable testing methods that can also prevent the use of DNA evidence at trial.  One New York Judge recently tossed out several DNA samples for the lab’s failure to use proper testing procedures.

For example, the now famous Amanda Knox case was decided, in part, based on the poor handling of DNA evidence obtained by the prosecutors.  In her case, the prosecution relied heavily on DNA evidence found on a knife and bra clasp in order to convict Ms. Knox.  However, a review of the authorities’ collection and handling of this evidence brought into question its validity.  The authorities in Ms. Knox’s case allowed the DNA evidence to be stored in regular plastic bags where moisture can build up and degrade the samples.  They also failed to properly test the knife at issue and confused potato starch for bleach, calling into question their testing methods and abilities.  The Knox case demonstrates just some of the issues that can come into play with DNA evidence and its admissibility.

As you can see, DNA evidence is not always accurate, nor is is always admissible.  If you or someone you know has been charged or convicted of a crime and DNA evidence is an issue, contact one of the experienced criminal law attorneys at Hipskind & McAninch for a FREE CONSULTATION.  Contact us at: 618-641-9189 (IL) | 314-312-2930 (MO) |

Authored by: Brady McAninch

Request a free case review
Award Icon

Avvo-Rated Excellent

Award Icon

The Bar Association of Metropolitan St. Louis

Award Icon

Super Lawyers® Rising Stars

Award Icon

The St. Clair County Bar Association

Award Icon

NTA Top 40 Under 40

Award Icon

Nation's Premier Top Ten Attorney

Award Icon

Illinois State Bar Association

Award Icon

AIOFLA 2015 10 Best Client Satisfaction

Award Icon

Proud Member of Belleville Chamber of Commerce

Quote Icon

John Hipskind was amazing! He was reliable, honest, and made me feel confident. John was always there when I had questions and very responsive…

Cori H.
Quote Icon

I can’t say enough good things about John. He truly cares about providing the best possible representation for his clients. I would highly recommend him!

John F.
Quote Icon

Brady did an outstanding job. I didn’t have to do anything or miss any work due to his exceptional service!! I would recommend him to anyone!

Erin H.
Quote Icon

I had a wonderful experience with my attorney Brady. He showed compassion and was always there to answer any of my questions.

Charlotte D.
Quote Icon

Brady helped facilitate my medical appointments, and made sure everything went smoothly. He settled my claim in a relatively short time.

Jeffrey M.
Quote Icon

John Hipskind was always a phone call or text away (we heard back from him within minutes). We are so pleased! You will be happy to have chosen him!

Jess M.